
The Famiyo Table · Episode 523:28
Wall Display or Phone? The Real Cost of a Smart Family Calendar Before You Buy
Family-budget blogger Tom Hadley works out the three-year cost of Skylight, Hearth and Jam, explains where wall displays really shine, and why most families with kids are better off starting with a free app.
About this episode
Before you put a smart family calendar in your Black Friday basket, listen to this. Host Oliver talks with family-budget blogger Tom Hadley about wall displays like Skylight Calendar and Hearth Display, the subscription app Jam Family Calendar, and a free app on the phones you already own. Tom does the maths on the real three-year cost of hardware plus subscriptions, explains where displays really shine (a glanceable kitchen hub, very young kids, grandparents) and where they fall short (one wall, kids without email, stars and rewards behind a subscription), and shares five questions to ask before you buy, including the old-tablet trick.
Key takeaways
- Compare the three-year cost, not the sticker price: hardware plus the subscription that unlocks the features you want.
- At the prices listed at the time of recording, Hearth comes to about $958 over three years with yearly membership ($699 display plus $86.40 a year), Skylight to about $387 ($149.99 display plus Calendar Plus at $79 a year) and Jam to $360 on the yearly plan.
- Displays shine as a glanceable kitchen hub, for very young children without a device and for grandparents who prefer to look at a wall.
- Displays fall short away from the kitchen: on Hearth, kids without an email account can only use the shared display, and stars and rewards on Skylight and Hearth sit behind a subscription.
- Famiyo's free plan covers up to 3 family members and 1 repeating task and includes the calendar, chores with points, the rewards shop and statistics, with no ads and no hardware; kids join on their own phone with a 6-character code.
- Five questions before you buy: what is the actual problem, how old are your kids and do they have a device, what is the three-year cost, have you tried a free app for a month, and who will update it?
- An old tablet on the kitchen counter with a family app open gives you most of the wall-display experience for free.
- Never pay for hardware to solve a habit problem: agree who updates the calendar and when you look at it together.
In this episode
Oliver (host)
Host of The Famiyo Table and a dad of two who would like to think he is fairly organised.
Tom Hadley (guest)
Dad of three and author of a family-budget blog that works out the real cost of what families buy.
Mentioned in this episode
Skylight Calendar
Calendar displays from $149.99; stars and rewards are part of Calendar Plus, $79 a year (prices at the time of recording).
Hearth Display
27-inch wall touchscreen at $699 with a Family Membership from $9 a month or $86.40 a year.
Jam Family Calendar
Subscription family calendar that turns forwarded emails into events; $15.99 a month or $120 a year after a 30-day trial.
Famiyo vs Skylight Calendar
famiyo.app/compare/famiyo-vs-skylight/
Famiyo vs Hearth Display
famiyo.app/compare/famiyo-vs-hearth/
Famiyo vs Jam Family Calendar
famiyo.app/compare/famiyo-vs-jam/
Best Family Organizer Apps in 2026
famiyo.app/best/family-organizer-apps/
Famiyo
Free family calendar and chore app for iPhone and Android, made by the team behind this podcast.
Links from this episode
Try what we talked about
Famiyo is a free family app with a shared, colour-coded calendar, reminders for the people involved in each event, and chores with points and rewards for kids. Move the family schedule out of one person's head and into a place everyone can see.
Questions from this episode
Is a Skylight or Hearth display worth it?
It can be if you want an always-on kitchen screen, have very young children without a device, or want grandparents to see the calendar at a glance. Compare the three-year cost first: the display plus the subscription that unlocks stars, rewards and routines.
How much does a smart family calendar cost over three years?
At the prices listed at the time of recording: Hearth about $958 with the yearly membership, Skylight about $387 with Calendar Plus, and Jam $360 on its yearly plan. A free app on the phones you already own can cost nothing.
Can I use a tablet as a family calendar display?
Yes. An old tablet on a stand in the kitchen, with your family calendar app open, gives you most of the benefits of a wall display without buying new hardware.
What is a free alternative to Skylight and Hearth for families with kids?
Famiyo puts a shared family calendar, chores with points and a rewards shop on every family phone. Its free plan covers up to 3 family members with no ads, and kids join with a 6-character code instead of an email.
Full transcript
Plain text versionCold open
Tom Hadley: Every November I get the same message from readers. "Tom, should I buy the big calendar screen for the kitchen? It's on offer." And my answer is always the same question back: "What problem are you trying to solve?" Because if the problem is that nobody looks at the calendar, a screen might help. But if the problem is that nobody does their chores, a seven-hundred-dollar screen won't fix that. It will just display it, in very high resolution.
Welcome to The Famiyo Table
Oliver: Hello, and welcome to The Famiyo Table, the podcast about the real, everyday work of running a family, and how to make it a little lighter. I'm Oliver, dad of two, owner of one slightly judgemental cat, and, as of this week, the proud recipient of approximately forty emails telling me that this is the best time of year to buy a smart family calendar.
Oliver: This episode is coming out just before Thanksgiving and Black Friday, which is exactly when those adverts start following you around the internet. So before anyone puts a wall display in their basket, I wanted to sit down with someone who has done the maths. Tom Hadley is a dad of three and writes a family-budget blog where he takes apart the real cost of things families buy. Tom, welcome to the table.
Tom Hadley: Thanks, Oliver. Happy to be here. And I should say up front: I'm not anti-gadget. I have a house full of them. My kids would tell you I'm the reason we own three different smart speakers that all mishear the word "pasta".
Oliver: [Laughs.] Good to know we're among friends. And I'll put my own cards on the table as well, as I did in episode one: this podcast is made by the team behind Famiyo, which is an app, not a screen. So you can decide how much to trust me. That's partly why I wanted Tom here. Tom, how did you end up writing about family calendars of all things?
Tom Hadley: By accident, really. I started the blog to track our household spending after our third child was born. Nappies, school uniforms, the usual. And I noticed that a surprising number of our "small" costs were subscriptions. Little monthly amounts we'd signed up for during a stressful week and never looked at again. Family organisation tools were one of them. So I started comparing them properly, with spreadsheets, and readers seemed to like it.
Oliver: Spreadsheets. My kind of guest. Let's start with the products themselves, then. When people say "smart family calendar", what are they actually talking about?
What a wall display actually is
Tom Hadley: Broadly, two kinds of things. The first is a dedicated screen that lives on the wall or the kitchen counter and shows the family calendar, chore lists and so on. The two big names people ask me about are Skylight Calendar and Hearth Display. The second kind is a family calendar app on the phones you already own. Some services are a bit of both: they sell a screen and also have a companion app.
Oliver: Let's take them one by one. Skylight first.
Tom Hadley: Skylight sells calendar displays, both wall and countertop versions, and according to their website the displays start at $149.99. There's a companion app for iPhone, Android and a desktop app. And to be fair to them, Skylight says you can use the service without buying a display at all. The thing families need to know is that the stars and rewards for kids, the bit that turns chores into something motivating, sits in a subscription called Calendar Plus, which is $79 a year at the time of recording.
Oliver: And Hearth?
Tom Hadley: Hearth is the big one. It's a 27-inch wall-mounted touchscreen, listed at $699. Then there's the Hearth Family Membership, which is $9 a month or $86.40 a year, and that membership is where the lists, routines, stars and rewards live. There are companion apps for iPhone and Android, but one detail matters a lot for families with younger kids: children without an email account can't use the companion app. They use the shared display.
Oliver: So the screen on the wall is the kids' way in.
Tom Hadley: Exactly. Which is fine when they're standing in the kitchen. Less fine when they're at football practice, or in their bedroom, or at the other parent's house.
Oliver: And you mentioned a third one before we started recording.
Tom Hadley: Jam Family Calendar. Jam isn't a screen, it's an app for iPhone, Android and the web. Its clever trick is that you can forward emails to it, the school newsletter, the party invitation, and it turns them into calendar events. But there's no free plan. After a 30-day trial it's $15.99 a month or $120 a year. So I lump it in with the displays in my spreadsheets, because in money terms it behaves like one: you're signing up for an ongoing cost.
Doing the maths: the three-year cost
Oliver: This is the bit I was looking forward to. Tom, walk us through the real cost. Not the price on the box.
Tom Hadley: Right. The mistake almost everyone makes is to compare the sticker price. But a family calendar isn't a one-week purchase. If it works, you use it for years. So I always look at three years, because that's roughly how long a family's routine stays similar before kids change school or start secondary or whatever.
Tom Hadley: Let's start with Hearth, because it's the most dramatic. The display is $699. The membership, if you pay yearly, is $86.40. Over three years that's $259.20 in membership. Add the screen and you're at $958.20. If you pay monthly instead, $9 a month is $108 a year, $324 over three years, and you're at $1,023.
Oliver: Just over a thousand dollars for a calendar.
Tom Hadley: For a calendar with stars and rewards, yes. And look, it's a beautiful screen. But that's the number. Now Skylight. The cheapest display is $149.99. If you want the stars and rewards, Calendar Plus is $79 a year, so $237 over three years. Total: $386.99. Cheaper than Hearth by a lot, but still nearly four hundred dollars.
Oliver: And Jam?
Tom Hadley: Jam has no hardware, so it's just the subscription. Paying yearly, $120 a year, $360 over three years. Paying monthly, $15.99 times twelve is $191.88 a year, which is $575.64 over three years. That monthly versus yearly gap is something I see all the time: people start monthly "just to try it" and never switch.
Oliver: And then there's the option of an app on the phones you already have.
Tom Hadley: Right. And this is where I have to be careful, because it's your company's product.
Oliver: Please be careful. I want you to be.
Tom Hadley: So, Famiyo's free plan covers up to three family members and one repeating task, and the calendar, chores with points, the rewards shop and statistics are all included in it, with no ads. There's no hardware. So for a parent and two kids, or two parents and one child, the three-year cost can genuinely be zero. If you're a bigger family, or you want lots of repeating chores, there's an optional Premium plan, monthly or yearly, that removes the limits. Check the current price in the app, but the point is that the free plan isn't a stripped-down trial: the points and rewards, the bit that Skylight and Hearth charge a subscription for, are in it.
Oliver: That's a fair summary, and I'll add the honest caveat myself: we're a family of four, so in our house we'd be past the free limit. The comparison that matters is what you get for the money, and whether you're paying for a screen you actually need.
Tom Hadley: Exactly. My rule on the blog is: never pay for hardware to solve a habit problem.
The costs nobody puts on the box
Oliver: Before we move on, are there costs beyond the screen and the subscription? Things people forget?
Tom Hadley: A few, and they're small individually, which is exactly why people miss them. The first is what I call the subscription you can't easily leave. Once your routines, your stars history and your kids' rewards live inside a paid membership, cancelling means losing them. So the price you agreed to in year one quietly becomes the price you keep paying in year three, whether or not the family still uses it every day.
Oliver: The sunk-cost problem.
Tom Hadley: Exactly. You think, well, we paid for the screen, we can't stop paying for the membership now, or the screen is just a picture frame. Which, to be fair, some of them are rather nice picture frames. But that's an expensive photo album.
Tom Hadley: The second is the household logistics. Somebody has to mount it, find a socket near the right wall, and keep it on the Wi-Fi. That's an afternoon, and in a lot of houses it's the same person who already does everything else. Third, kids grow. The display that's perfect for a five-year-old picking a sticker is often ignored by the same child at nine, who wants their own device and their own space. So the useful life can be shorter than people expect.
Oliver: And the fourth one? I can see you have a fourth one.
Tom Hadley: [Laughs.] I always have a fourth one. Duplication. Almost every family I talk to who bought a display still ends up with the old shared calendar on the parents' phones, plus a paper list on the fridge for the shopping, plus a WhatsApp group. The screen doesn't replace those by itself. So now the information lives in four places instead of three. Unless you deliberately switch everything over, the gadget adds to the mess.
Oliver: So the honest version of the maths includes the time and the duplication, not just the dollars.
Tom Hadley: Yes. My readers are always surprised that the biggest cost isn't on the receipt. It's in the minutes every week spent copying things from one place to another.
Oliver: That's very true in our house. Before we moved everything into one calendar, my wife kept the real calendar, I kept a hopeful copy, and the fridge had a third version that was mostly decorative.
Tom Hadley: The decorative calendar. Every family has one.
Where the displays really shine
Oliver: I don't want this to turn into an episode where we just bash screens, because I think they do some things brilliantly. Where do they win?
Tom Hadley: Three places, in my experience. First, glanceability. A big screen in the kitchen is in your eyeline when you're making breakfast. You don't have to unlock anything. For a family where the parents are already overloaded with notifications, that calm, always-on view is genuinely nice.
Tom Hadley: Second, very young children. If your kids are four or five and don't have a phone or tablet, a touchscreen at their height is a lovely way for them to see their morning routine. Little pictures, big buttons, tapping a star. Pre-readers can follow it.
Tom Hadley: And third, grandparents and visitors. Granny comes over, looks at the wall, sees that Thursday is swimming. Nobody has to send her a link.
Oliver: That third one rings true. My mother-in-law would much rather look at a wall than install anything.
Tom Hadley: And there's a fourth, more emotional one: some families just like the object. It's a bit like a beautiful paper planner. If it makes you happy every morning and you can afford it, that's a perfectly good reason. I'm a budget blogger, not a joy police officer.
Oliver: [Laughs.] Noted. So where do they fall short?
Where the displays fall short
Tom Hadley: The biggest one is simple geography. A wall display lives on one wall. Family life doesn't. The moment you need to check something, you're not in the kitchen. You're at the school gate, or at work, or in the car park at the dentist trying to remember whether the next appointment was the 12th or the 21st. So you end up using the companion app on your phone anyway, and the screen becomes a very expensive second view of the same calendar.
Oliver: Which is fine for the parents, but what about the kids?
Tom Hadley: That's the second issue, and it's the one I think families underestimate. With Hearth, kids without their own email account can't use the companion app; they use the display. So for a ten-year-old, their chores and their stars exist on a screen in the kitchen. If they're at their friend's house on Saturday and want to know what they still need to do, or how many stars they have, they can't check.
Oliver: And most ten-year-olds don't have email.
Tom Hadley: Most parents I know actively don't want their ten-year-old to have an email address yet. Which is why I like the approach where a child can join with a code. In Famiyo, a parent creates the child's profile and the child joins on their own phone with a six-character code, no email, no password. That's a big deal for families with kids in that eight-to-twelve range.
Oliver: And the third issue?
Tom Hadley: The subscriptions. The pattern I see again and again is: the screen is the big purchase, but the motivating part, stars, rewards, routines, sits behind a subscription. Skylight puts stars and rewards in Calendar Plus. Hearth puts lists, routines, stars and rewards in the Family Membership. So the screen gets you a calendar, and the thing that actually changes kids' behaviour is a recurring cost on top.
Oliver: There's also a mixed-phones question, which comes up a lot in our inbox.
Tom Hadley: Yes. Most of these services do have iPhone and Android companion apps, so that's not usually the dealbreaker. The question I'd ask is: who can use it on their own device, and what does each person need to sign up? That's where the differences hide. And languages, actually. Both Hearth's companion app and Jam show English only on their App Store listings, which matters for bilingual families or for grandparents who'd rather use their own language. Famiyo is in eight languages: English, Polish, German, Spanish, French, Italian, Portuguese and Russian.
Oliver: I didn't pay him to say that.
Tom Hadley: He didn't. I checked the App Store myself.
The habit problem: what actually makes a family calendar work
Oliver: Let's go back to your cold open, Tom. You said a screen won't fix a chores problem. Say more.
Tom Hadley: So, I run a little survey on the blog every year. Not scientific, just readers telling me what worked. And the families who stick with any system, paper, screen or app, have a few things in common. One person doesn't own it alone. There's a fixed moment each week when they look at it together. And the kids have their own part of it, something that's theirs, that they can check and tick off.
Tom Hadley: None of that is about the hardware. A wall display in a family where only Mum updates it is just a very nice-looking version of Mum's head.
Oliver: [Laughs.] I'm going to steal that.
Tom Hadley: Please do. And the flip side is also true: an app that nobody opens doesn't help either. So the question isn't screen versus app. It's: where will each person in this family actually look, every day, without being reminded?
Oliver: And for most families with kids old enough to have a phone, where is that?
Tom Hadley: The phone. For better or worse, that's where they look. So I'd rather put the chores and the points where their eyes already are, and send them a gentle notification when there's a new task, than hope they walk past the kitchen wall at the right moment.
Oliver: In our house, the thing that changed it for my daughter, who's nine, was getting a notification when a reward she'd been saving for was approved. She'd been saving points for a cinema trip for three weeks. The moment it landed on her phone, she was more motivated by that than by anything we'd ever stuck on the fridge.
Tom Hadley: That's exactly it. The reward has to be real, and the progress has to be visible to the child wherever they are.
A simple decision guide before you buy
Oliver: Let's make this practical. Someone is listening on the day before Thanksgiving, the Black Friday deal is in their basket. What should they ask themselves?
Tom Hadley: I have five questions. First: what's the actual problem? Write it down in one sentence. "Nobody knows what's happening on Saturday" is a calendar problem. "The kids don't do their chores" is a motivation problem. "I'm the only one who knows anything" is a sharing problem. A screen helps mostly with the first one.
Tom Hadley: Second: how old are your kids, and do they have their own device? If they're under six and don't, a display can be lovely. If they're older and have a phone or a tablet, putting their chores on their own device will usually work better.
Tom Hadley: Third: what's the three-year cost? Not the deal price. Hardware plus three years of whatever subscription unlocks the features you actually want. Write the number down. If it makes you wince, that's information.
Tom Hadley: Fourth: try the free version first. Run your family on an app for one month before you buy anything. If, after a month, you still find yourself wishing for a big screen in the kitchen, great, you've learned something. And here's a tip I give a lot: you probably already own a screen. An old tablet on a stand on the kitchen counter, with the family app open, gets you about eighty per cent of the wall-display experience for nothing.
Oliver: We actually suggest that on the Famiyo comparison pages. An old tablet as a kitchen screen.
Tom Hadley: It's a great trick. Fifth and last: who will update it? If the answer is "me, as usual", fix that first. Give everyone a role. Otherwise the shiny new screen is just a new place for one person to carry everything.
Oliver: Let me sum that up. One: name the problem. Two: match it to your kids' ages and devices. Three: calculate the three-year cost. Four: try a free app for a month, maybe on an old tablet. Five: decide who updates it.
Tom Hadley: Perfect. And if you do all that and still want the Hearth on the wall, buy it with a clear conscience. It's your kitchen.
Why we think an app wins for most families with kids
Oliver: I'll ask you directly, and I'll accept whatever answer you give. For a typical family with school-age kids, which way would you go?
Tom Hadley: For most families with kids roughly six and up, I'd start with an app on the phones you already have. And of the ones I've looked at, Famiyo is the one I'd point most families with kids towards, for a few specific reasons. The calendar, chores with points and a rewards shop are in one app, so you're not juggling a calendar in one place and a chore chart in another. The points and rewards are included on the free plan, which is unusual. Kids join on their own phone with a code, no email. It runs on iPhone, iPad and Android with live sync, so mixed-phone families work. And there's no hardware.
Tom Hadley: Where I'd consider a display instead: very young kids with no device, a family that really values the always-on kitchen view and has the budget, or grandparents who need to see it without touching anything. And if your main pain is the flood of school emails, Jam's email forwarding is a genuinely clever feature, as long as you're happy with the subscription.
Oliver: That feels fair. And it's consistent with how we rank things on our own site: Skylight is listed as the best wall display, Hearth as the best large touchscreen, Jam as the best for turning emails into events. They're good at what they're built for.
Tom Hadley: They are. It's just that most families aren't actually short of a screen. They're short of a shared system.
A listener question
Oliver: Before the rapid-fire round, a listener question that fits perfectly. It's from a mum of two who writes: "We already bought a wall display last year. The kids loved it for a month and now it's mostly a clock. Did we waste our money?" Tom?
Tom Hadley: First, no guilt. A month of the kids loving it isn't nothing. But I'd ask what changed after that month. Usually the novelty wore off, nobody was checking in with them about their stars, and the rewards weren't things they cared about. That's not the screen's fault, and it's fixable.
Tom Hadley: So I'd do three things. Sit down with the kids and pick rewards they actually want, together. Agree a weekly moment where you look at the week as a family. And if your kids are old enough for their own device, give them access to their own chores and points there, so the system follows them out of the kitchen. If the display still earns its place on the wall after that, brilliant. If it doesn't, you can keep it as the very nice kitchen clock and stop paying for the parts you no longer use.
Oliver: Keep the clock, cancel the bit you don't use. Very practical.
Rapid-fire round
Oliver: Tom, you know what time it is. Rapid-fire round. Short questions, short answers.
Tom Hadley: Go.
Oliver: The most expensive word in family budgeting?
Tom Hadley: "Monthly."
Oliver: The best free family-organisation tool that isn't an app?
Tom Hadley: A ten-minute Sunday chat with the calendar open.
Oliver: Black Friday: buy or wait?
Tom Hadley: Wait a month, use the free version, then decide.
Oliver: One subscription every family should cancel tonight?
Tom Hadley: The one you can't remember signing up for.
Oliver: A reward your kids would work hardest for?
Tom Hadley: Choosing what's for dinner on Friday. Costs nothing. Absolute power.
Oliver: [Laughs.] And finally: the best place for a family calendar?
Tom Hadley: Wherever every person in the family will see it without being nagged. Usually, that's their pocket.
Closing thoughts
Oliver: Tom Hadley, thank you. This is exactly the conversation I wanted to have before the shopping weekend.
Tom Hadley: Thank you, Oliver. And if I can leave people with one thought: the most expensive organiser is the one you buy to avoid a conversation. Have the conversation first. Then, if you still need a gadget, you'll know exactly which one.
Oliver: Have the conversation first. Lovely.
Oliver: To everyone listening: if a friend has a wall display in their basket right now, send them this episode. They might thank you, or they might buy it anyway, but at least they'll know the three-year number.
Oliver: And if you'd like to try the phone-first approach, a shared family calendar, chores with points and a rewards shop, without buying anything, Famiyo is free to download on iPhone and Android. You'll find the links at famiyo.app and in the show notes, together with our comparison pages for Skylight, Hearth and Jam if you'd like to check the details yourself.
Oliver: I'm Oliver, this has been The Famiyo Table. Happy Thanksgiving to everyone celebrating, and see you next week.
[Tom laughs. Theme music up, 10 seconds, fade out.]
Follow The Famiyo Table
New episodes in your favourite podcast app.